Giving 360 degree feedback guidance video stills

Giving 360 degree feedback: 5 key guidelines for feedback providers

360 degree appraisals are often approached with a little trepidation, and not just by those due to receive feedback. Being asked to provide feedback, particularly for a line manager or senior colleague, can be challenging.

Not offering sufficient guidance to those giving the feedback is a common problem. This can lead to skewing of the results which compromises the overall validity and value of the whole 360 process. It’s therefore essential that you educate and support people being asked to provide 360 degree feedback.

As a supplier of 360 degree appraisal tools, we help clients with this by creating a short instructional video that offers clear guidance and practical tips for those giving 360 feedback.

Below are some key tips, guidelines and best practice advice for you to share with your feedback providers.

Explain what the 360 degree feedback programme is for

Giving this framing is useful to remind people what their feedback is to be used for and why it is important. You could say something like:

The feedback you and others provide enables personal development by giving the individual diverse and honest feedback on their capability and competency from the people who work with them. They can then use this to help build on key strengths and explore development areas.

Offer reassurances over anonymity

  • If your 360 feedback tool is managed by a third party, tell employees this
  • Explain that only an individual’s line manager is identifiable to the feedback receiver in the final report
  • Reiterate that feedback from direct reports or peers will only be reported in groups of three or more.

Encourage honesty and integrity

Emphasise the importance of providing honest responses. Encourage feedback providers to:

  • Use the whole rating scale
  • Trust their gut reaction and move swiftly through the questions as their immediate response is likely to be most reliable
  • Test their feedback against examples to make sure it is the right decision
  • Be open and honest.

Keep in mind too that the extent to which one is able to observe a colleague’s behaviours will vary depending on their business relationship with the person in question, so suggest that they base their feedback only on the behaviours directly observed.

Avoid common pitfalls

Make feedback providers aware of these common pitfalls before they complete a 360 questionnaire:

  • Leniency (over or under rating) occurs when a feedback provider gives answers that are much higher or lower than the actual level of what’s been observed. If someone is answering most questions at one end of the scale, it’s possible they could be being either too harsh or too lenient
  • ‘Halo effect’ is when the feedback provider allows an overall impression of the recipient’s behaviour to influence them, either positively or negatively, on all other aspects they rate them on
  • ‘Recency’ (last event) happens when responses are influenced by a recent instance or event that may have had a positive or negative impact. Feedback providers should instead consider what they’ve observed over a longer period (i.e. the last year).

All of these potential issues can be avoided by advising feedback providers to simply focus on one question at a time and try not to allow an overall opinion or relationship with the participant to influence responses.

Consider your ‘open comments’

A typical 360 degree feedback questionnaire will often include one or more ‘open response’ or ‘free text’ questions. Feedback providers must keep in mind that what they write is recorded (and reported) word-for-word. With this in mind, make sure that:

  • Any comments provided are intended to help the individual improve behaviour
  • They provide relevant, actionable feedback
  • Comments are constructive and supportive
  • They keep feedback concise and clear.

Following this guidance should ensure all of those asked to provide 360 feedback are clear on exactly what’s expected of them in the process. This, in turn, will mean those receiving the feedback gain even greater and more useful insights about their strengths and development needs.

Our other products & services

Related resources

360 degree feedback tools: A comprehensive guide for HR buyers

In this guide, we outline a range of criteria, considerations and questions for prospective buyers of 360 feedback programmes. This should provide a solid basis for a brief.

360 degree feedback rating scales: What’s best practice?

This article explores different types of 360 degree feedback rating scales commonly used and considers the scenarios when each of them is most suitable.

360 degree feedback issues: 7 of the biggest pitfalls and how to solve them

Blog offering expert advice on how to avoid seven of the most common issues reported with 360 degree feedback.

Stay ahead of the curve. Get our HR and L&D monthly digest and news about our services delivered straight to your inbox.